HomeOpinionsWhat's riskier: a car or a house?

What is riskier: a car or a house?

Data shows that mortgage lending has a lower default rate. So why is financing a home still so difficult?

Which poses more risk to a bank: financing a vehicle or financing a home? The intuitive answer might favor the car loan due to its lower amount and shorter term. However, when we observe the actual behavior of credit in the Dominican Republic, a paradox emerges: the housing loan portfolio presents considerably better risk indicators than the consumer loan portfolio.

At the close of 2025, the Superintendency of Banks reported a delinquency rate of just 0.73% for mortgage loans, compared to 4.36% for consumer loans. The difference is also reflected in the default rate—the proportion of outstanding debt that falls into arrears—: 1.8% for mortgage loans and 6.0% for consumer loans.

The data favors housing

Dominican regulations classify consumer credit as loans granted to individuals for the purchase of goods and services. Mortgage credit for housing, on the other hand, is specifically defined as long-term financing secured by the property itself, whether acquired or constructed.

The Superintendency does not publish a delinquency rate specifically for vehicles in the aforementioned report, so it would be incorrect to directly compare 0.73% against a vehicle-related figure that we don't have. However, the contrast between housing and consumer loans remains revealing.

So too is the way the market prices risk. In January 2026, the Central Bank reported an average interest rate of 16.23% for consumer loans, while mortgages averaged 11.93%. In other words, the financial market itself charges, on average, a higher premium for consumer credit.

There are economic reasons for this. A car begins to depreciate from the moment it enters circulation; it is exposed to accidents, deterioration, and obsolescence, and after several years, its value can be much lower than the original.

A home can also lose value, but the property that guarantees a mortgage has a different characteristic: it incorporates land, has a much longer useful life and, in consolidated markets, can maintain or increase its nominal value for extended periods.

So why is it more difficult?

The bank has legitimate reasons to analyze a mortgage more carefully. It typically involves a larger amount, terms of 15, 20, or even 30 years, and a much longer exposure to changes in the borrower's income and interest rates.

Furthermore, establishing and eventually enforcing a property guarantee is a more complex process than registering or recovering a vehicle.

But it's one thing for the process to require more analysis and another for the asset to necessarily be riskier.

The observed results tell an important story: Dominican families tend to protect their mortgage payments. The mortgage portfolio reached RD$443.17 billion in 2025, growing by 13.2%, and even with that growth, it maintained a delinquency rate of less than 1%.

Facilitating credit without relaxing risk

This does not mean that banks should approve mortgages without verifying income, ability to pay, or credit history. Doing so would be irresponsible.

The point is different: if the housing demonstrates superior credit quality, the system should seek mechanisms to reduce the frictions that hinder its financing.

This could mean more streamlined processes, better guarantee mechanisms, greater mortgage competition, insurance, guarantee funds, securitization, and prudent use of institutional savings to expand long-term funding.

A car satisfies an important need. A home, in addition, builds family wealth.

If the data shows that the mortgage portfolio has lower delinquency and lower default rates than consumer credit, we should ask ourselves why many families feel that it is easier to finance a vehicle than to access the home they will use for decades.

The goal shouldn't be to make it harder to finance cars. It should be to make it easier to finance homes when the actual risk and ability to pay allow it.

Recommended readings:

From mortgage loans to the stock market

Master plan: a large plot of land does not make a great project

The future of Santo Domingo is outside the center







Be the first to know about the most exclusive news

Advertisingspot_img
The content and opinions expressed here are solely those of the author. Inmobiliario.do assumes no responsibility for these statements and does not consider them binding on its editorial view.
Omar Castillo Zavala
Omar Castillo Zavala
Civil engineer specializing in feasibility and real estate development.
Related Articles
Advertising Banner Coral Golf Resort SIMA 2025
Advertising
Advertising spot_img