Construction Begins “It’s Not Cheaper”: Claims of Haitian Labor Costs Debunked…

“It’s not cheaper”: Claims about the cost of Haitian labor in the Dominican Republic are denied

Escarlin Pozo

SANTO DOMINGO.– The construction sector in the Dominican Republic faces a complex scenario, marked by a shortage of Haitian labor, a slowdown in investment – ​​both public and private – and persistent informal employment.

This was the warning issued by the former presidents of the Dominican College of Engineers, Architects and Surveyors (Codia), Martín Concepción and Teodoro Tejada, during the third episode of the program “La Ventana de El Inmobiliario”.

During her participation, Concepción suggested that one of the measures that the Government could implement, from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Mirex), is the issuance of work visas to regulate the issue of migration and foreign labor in the country.

“When I was president of Codia, 25 years ago, I remember saying that the Dominican government and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs should take the issue of immigrants seriously by granting work visas. And they never did,” he noted.

The civil engineer also spoke about one of the causes that influences the decline of the construction sector, citing what was expressed by the economist and former director of the General Directorate of Internal Taxes (DGII), Magín Díaz, who maintains that the deportations of illegal immigrants could be impacting the industry.

“The issue of deportations of undocumented immigrants may be impacting the sector, although there is no firm data on this. But if we consider that 85% of construction operates in the informal labor market, according to data from the Continuous Labor Force Survey published by the Central Bank, there is no doubt that this issue may be influencing the sector's performance in recent months,” Díaz explained in a publication released in early May.

Concepción stated that, when he was president of Codia, the government in power did not give importance to the regulation of immigrants through visas, which, he said, was due to a “clash of political interests”.

“Corruption isn’t just about those who control the border; corruption also involves the consuls who have been on the Dominican side doing business with visas,” he declared.

For his part, Teodoro Tejada revealed that a “mafia” operates in the country that conditions the continued employment of Haitian workers on construction sites, demanding increasingly higher payments to avoid being arrested or deported.

“I had to give him 10,000 pesos, then I gave him 18,000; now it’s 25,000. So, I tell him 'no, stay, because there’s a powerful teachers’ mafia here',” he recounted, revealing the payments they demand to release the detained Haitians.

Tejada commented that there is a misconception about Haitian labor, since —contrary to what many think— “it is not cheaper.”.

He highlighted that, currently, many Haitians work as construction foremen with a high level of experience, a result of the dedication they have put into learning the trade.

“There are great tradespeople who lay floors, install tiles; electricians and plumbers. These Haitians have dedicated themselves and learned a lot, it's true, and they are good people,” he explained. 

Both engineers agreed that, in the workplace, they try to comply with the provisions of the Dominican Republic's Labor Code, specifically with what is stated in article 135 regarding the so-called 80/20 rule for workers.

For this, we quote: “At least eighty percent of the total number of workers in a company must be made up of Dominicans.”.

“It’s a fact that migration, immigrants, are an important element of development and construction. In my particular case, I do my best to comply with the 80/20 rule. And it’s very difficult to achieve the 80% Dominican quota, but we’re mobilizing the entire country to try to make it happen,” Martín said.  

Economic overview of the construction sector

Both experts discussed the construction sector from an economic perspective and the policies being developed in the nation regarding investment in construction.

Martín Concepción compared the annual growth that the sector is experiencing, taking into account its development before the COVID-19 pandemic.

“It is growing annually at an average rate of 1.7%, whereas until 2019, before the pandemic, it was growing at 5.5% per year,” he noted.

For his part, Teodoro Tejada stated that, in October 2021, the then Minister of Economy, Planning and Development, Miguel Ceara Hatton, had reported on a program that private investment was 85% while public investment was 15%.

At that time, he emphasized that this proportion showed a high weight of the private sector in real estate development and construction.

He noted that private construction projects expand when there are incentives, such as low interest rates and the release of reserve requirements from the Central Bank of the Dominican Republic.

“Real estate projects grow in the private sector when there are incentives. This includes the Central Bank's interest rates and significant release of reserve requirements, but when there are no incentives for the private sector, the private sector becomes constrained,” he emphasized.

Otherwise, he specified that when those conditions decrease, the private sector shrinks or slows down.

During the interview, Teodoro quoted Professor Juan Bosch: “When the government construction industry stops, the country stops,” highlighting that more than 90% of public projects end up involving the private sector.

He also mentioned that the private sector has had to face high interest rates, difficulties in accessing loans, and high dollar volatility.

“So, in the private sector, the decline is due to a very high interest rate, very high loan difficulties, and a soaring dollar that forced the private sector to stand on two legs,” he said.

He also specified that in the first four months of the year, 29.5% of the investment in construction was not executed.

In that regard, the expert explained that public investment in construction has fallen from 4.5% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP)in 2004-2008, to 3.6% from 2012 to 2020, reaching only 2.1-2.5% currently

Photo: Justo Feliz.

Be the first to know about the most exclusive news

Advertisingspot_img
El Inmobiliario
El Inmobiliario
We are the Dominican Republic's leading media group, specializing in the real estate, construction, and tourism sectors. Our team of professionals focuses on providing valuable content, delivered with responsibility, commitment, respect, and a dedication to the truth.
Related Articles
Advertising Banner Coral Golf Resort SIMA 2025
Advertising
Advertising spot_img